Of all the somewhat crazy things, I ended up getting the Enforcers in a 185! Despite the fact that the title suggested 3 very different skis, there were a few things that played into this rather than just GregK (who obviously was a big influence, but also at the end I own my own decision
)
1) I had been thinking I was in between lengths in the blizzard while 184-185 had always felt right-ish for this kind of ski;
2) I had pretty exhaustively read reviews and watched videos on the whole spectrum there, and had it in my mind previously the enforcer was more like a katana or something really stiff.
3) I expect to be in quite a bit of chop just in general, where I ski, much more than float. Also, how I ski honestly is not as dynamic as I'd like it to be so hopefully some of the dampness will help out. I have felt kicked around on the QSTs in chop.
4) The discussion on "forgiving" underfoot (plus the flex patterns I'd seen on these skis from a number of reviews) was useful to me. I'd seen this a few places, not just from Greg. I think it was close, and ultimately thought some about the MFree vs the enforcer as an A/B at the end, some of the thoughts on getting through the chop...
5) Before this, I had landed on the MFree108 as my most likely choice (and this probably would have worked well, actually). It still potentially could have been better, IDK, as I slightly favor the perhaps even easier release on the tips and tails; but honestly, I don't know
Something that helped break a very close race (not the most important thing, but non-negligible in a near tie): the MFree was a little harder to get in my physical location, and $750 vs 600, and I could support a shop that has been good to me so far.
Lastly, I'm buying a $600 (right now) ski, not getting married to it. If it doesn't work out after a few days of skiing it, someone will buy it for a reasonable price and I'll try something different
The QST99s were not knocking it out of the park in deeper days
And yes, should be able to ski another 10 days this year, so will definitely get them out, maybe in the slush, definitely if there's fresh