I see plenty of skiers in new boots that still need adjustments in fore and aft -Even more are in boots that have not had proper cuff alignment done first.
Many were shop canted during initial fitting.
I would advise against canting before a skier gets enough time on snow - canting after all the other issues are resolved, and by trial and error testing with temporary shims before permanently grinding boot soles.
Warren Witherells advice still holds true:
1 Assessment
2 Footbeds
3 Fore and aft
4 Cuffs
5 Canting
The man who promoted canting understood that canting is the last step in a process that takes time.
A few thoughts on what holds true...
First of all what holds true is that Warren was a visionary that above all understood that the individual athlete could reach maximum performance if their equipment was adapted and manipulated to to bring the skier down the mountain fast and in balance. The best part about Warren was his ability to adapt his process as equipment changed as well as his ability to bring similar focus to other sports like waterskiing.
I know that many of the members out here want hard and fast rules to follow about equipment set-up. The tough part is that the human body has a way of testing your hard and fast rules.
What can be looked at inside of a shop without ever seeing a skier or athlete ski...
1. Assessment of the foot, lower leg, joint mobility of the ankle, arch, and the joints between 1st / 2nd met heads and 4th / 5th met heads.
2. Build a custom footbed, or choose a trim to fit that matches your arch and forefoot assessment, or choose not to use a footbed if your assessment dictates so.
3. Perform all fit grinds or punches to allow the foot to settle neutrally into the boot. This could include inner boot mods and or custom injected or molded liners.
4. Adjust the cuff of the boot to match the direction that lower leg comes off the bootboard sitting on the footbed. This is a static adjustment that does not need to be tested. If the leg goes outward the cuff goes out, if the leg goes inward the cuff goes in. Just like the bootboard is not a fit aid, The cuff adjustment on ski boots is not a cant adjustment.
After the above steps have been taken care of you move outside of the boot shell. The good news is that the first step of outside the boot adjustment can still be done inside the shop...
5. Do a cant assessment on a flat surface with the boot buckled race tight at the prescribe stance width for the skiers height and or hip width. At this point you can either choose to change the sole cant with either boot sole planing, or using shims between the lifters, or using intrasole cant shims from Cantology, or use canted lifter plates. Or you can simply write the indications of the cant assessment on the boot toe for the skier to test on hill before you make a permanent change to the boot sole. Best if you limit the on hill testing to a supervised task with a coach or ski instructor. Use all the modern tools available to confirm like video, timing, and a watchful eye. Be aware that using duct tape between the binding and the boot sole will detract from proper binding release functions.
Now as I have stated before, the very last adjustment is the on-hill only testing of your fore/aft positioning. Just cause there is currently no proven assessment technique for fore/aft balance inside of a shop.
6. On hill testing of delta either adding height to the heel or adding height to the toe. Ski 1 run heel raised, ski 1 run toe raised, ski 1 run stock delta. Ski mixed terrain, surface, speed, and turn shape each run. Keep open to the concept that if you have nailed all the other parts of the process the is a very high percentage chance that you will not have to make any fore/aft adjust to your set-up.
When working with athletes that have coaches with specific ideas of how they want their athletes set-up, respect those wishes. I have some coaches that have a high level of trust and allow me to do an accurate assessment, then go right into changing the boot sole cant. I have other coaches that appreciate the base work of doing the cant assessment, then they will perform the test of the cant prescription on the mountain in race conditions.
Just as a reality check of whether you want to believe in the deep thinkers of ski boot history... Warren's 2nd book came out before skis with deep sidecuts like 14 meters for SL and 30 meters for GS. Just like he wrote the second book to make corrections for the book "How The Racers Ski" If Warren was still alive today he would concede that with the current crop of boots, technique change, and the modern version of race ski sidecut, he would have to write another book to bring "The Athletic Skier" into the current century.