-- 11 more rolls of the dice....
That is of course another one of the infinite interesting things about every bottle of wine.
That Antigua Classica Rioja I posted a few pages back....First bottle was very good - second made me think I was mistaken - third again was very good.
Oh - I should add so no one gets the wrong idea, not all were emptied on the same night...
I had this experience several years ago. 2001 if I am remembering correctly. My brother is not into wine at all. But a friend of his who was had given him (sometime in the late 80s) 4 bottles of 1978 Sebastiani Barbera (Sonoma Valley). This was not a high end bottling, but the friend had raved about it being a great wine for the money when he gave them to my brother. He found them when he moved (2001) and gave them to me. I found some archived grocery flyers from 1980 or so advertising them for $2.74/bottle.
I knew:
1. They had not been stored properly (other than laying on their side in the back of a guest room closet)
2. Barbera has great acidity and ages fairly well (even though it is not a "long ager" either--the wine was 23 yrs old at this point)
3. It is easy to make good Barbera (and damn near impossible to make "great" Barbera)
4. Sebastiani is/was a highly competent, albeit fairly large, winery
5. Sonoma Valley is a great place to grow Barbera (even though there is little planted there)
I don't remember what my girlfriend (now wife) and I concocted to go with the first bottle. We pulled the cork. And then sieved all the pieces of cork out of the bottle as it crumbled. I said oh well and poured a glass.
To this day it remains one of the most sublime, deep, generous, complex wines I've ever had. I can taste it like it was yesterday. Depths of muted red berries, graphite, smoke, flint, raw meat, pepper . . . on and on. Beautiful. Ephemeral, as its character changed by the minute. Literally brings tears to my eyes recalling it.
Bottle 2, 3, and 4? Yeah, totally oxidized and undrinkable. Sigh. I could taste some of those things^ underneath, but the aldehyde made it unbearable.