I just liked the comment "I don't remember the Raddlers being this snappy". That's just so throwaway.. I mean it COULD be true! But..
I've been on Riddlers and Raddlers both - still have some I doubt I'll ever use - and they *are* relatively dead to the world for anything resembling surface feel.
But why in the name of all that proper reviewing, would you pick a tire that is like that instead of, like, actually sensitive modern rubber from any of a dozen other brands, and even something more responsive from WTB themselves?
I did understand your point - no one can call him out on what is essentially a subjective review. What I'm saying is, even for those of us who believe he had the experience he describes, it is far less than useful to have done the experience as he did.